BuyHomes for sale
Historic village houses, waterfront estates and island homes in Stonington Borough, Watch Hill and Fishers Island, and along the shoreline nearby.
01Our Listings
The homes we represent today, each with full details and photographs on our site.
All listings
01Shelter Harbor · Westerly, Rhode Island
10 Wagner Road
$5,495,000
A historic coastal estate operating as an established inn and event destination, ready to carry on as an inn or to become a private residence, a family retreat or a coastal compound.
View the listing
Pending
02Groton Long Point, Connecticut
Groton Long Point
$1,800,000
A Cape-style Colonial with a tower room, overlooking the tidal marsh and bordering conservation land, minutes from Groton Long Point's beaches.
View the listing
03Stonington Borough, Connecticut
Harboredge Dockominium
$60,000
Your own slip in the Borough, an easy sail to Fishers Island and Watch Hill, and a short walk to Water Street.
View the listing02On the Map
Our three villages and the shoreline around them. Select a number to see a listing, or a place name to see what's for sale there.
By trainAmtrak's Northeast Regional stops at New London, Mystic and Westerly.
By ferryYear-round to Fishers Island from New London, about 45 minutes.
By carJust off I-95: roughly two and a half to three hours from New York, under two from Boston.
Shoreline © OpenStreetMap contributors.
03By Type
Federal, Greek Revival and shingle-style houses, most within a walk of the harbor.
Frontage on the harbors, the bay and the open Sound.
Three acres and more: farms, meadows and private settings.
A place on the water for the boat, with or without the house.
Inns, shops and mixed-use buildings along the shoreline.
04The Villages
It's the first question most buyers ask. Here is how the three compare, and we're always glad to talk it through.
| Stonington BoroughConnecticut | Watch HillRhode Island | Fishers IslandNew York | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The feel | A year-round working village, with a fishing fleet, galleries and restaurants along Water Street. | A Victorian summer colony, with a beach, a small harbor and the Flying Horse Carousel. | A quiet, private island with a close-knit summer community. |
| The houses | Federal and Greek Revival village homes, harborfront houses, and estates on the points nearby. | Shingle-style summer cottages and oceanfront estates on the bluffs. | Shingle-style island houses and harborfront properties. |
| On the water | A protected deep-water harbor, with Fishers Island and Watch Hill a short sail away. | Little Narragansett Bay on one side, open Atlantic beaches on the other. | West and East Harbor, and the island's own shoreline. |
| The season | Lively all year. | At its fullest in summer, much quieter in winter. | At its fullest in summer, with a small year-round community. |
| Getting there | Minutes from I-95 and the Amtrak stations in Mystic and Westerly. | Minutes from Westerly and its Amtrak station. | A year-round ferry from New London, about 45 minutes. |
| Three-bedroom homes* | Sold for about $1.15M to $2.5M in 2026, roughly $1.75M on average. The highest prices are on the water. | Sold from about $1.7M in 2026, with waterfront estates at $7M and above. | Only a few island houses sell each year, and many sales are private. Ask us for recent figures. |
| Our office | 108 Water Street | 27 Bay Street | 643 Equestrian Avenue, with Shutters & Sails Fishers Island |
* Single-family sales recorded on the multiple listing services, January to October 2026. Each village sees only a handful of three-bedroom sales a year, so treat these figures as a guide.
05Working With Us
Most of our buyers are looking for a second home, and most won't be here every week. We work accordingly.
How you'll use the house, which villages appeal and what you'd like to spend.
We show you the places, not just the houses: the harbors, the beaches and the streets you'd walk every day.
On the market and coming soon, across all three villages and the shoreline nearby.
Clear advice on price and terms from people who know what comparable houses have sold for.
Flood zones and insurance, docks and permits, wells and septic, historic districts. We help you ask the right questions early.
Introductions to caretakers, contractors, marinas and local services, so the house is ready when you are.
06Before You Buy
The questions buyers new to this shoreline often don't think to ask.
Stonington is in Connecticut, Watch Hill in Rhode Island and Fishers Island in New York. Property taxes, closing customs and the role of attorneys differ from state to state. Because one team works across all three, we know the differences and can introduce you to the right local professionals.
Much of the waterfront here lies in mapped flood zones, which affects insurance costs and, for some houses, how they can be renovated. We'll help you look at flood maps, elevation certificates and insurance quotes early, before you're committed.
Parts of Stonington Borough and Watch Hill are historic districts, where some exterior changes may need approval. We'll tell you what applies to a house before you fall for it.
Docks are permitted by the state: Connecticut's Department of Energy and Environmental Protection and Rhode Island's Coastal Resources Management Council. Moorings are managed locally. A house with a dock and a house where you hope to build one are very different purchases, and we'll help you tell them apart.
Outside the village centers, many houses rely on a private well and a septic system. Inspections of both are an essential part of due diligence, and we'll help you arrange them.
The island is reached by ferry from New London, services are fewer in the off-season, and the market is small, so it pays to know what's coming. We work there with our partner, Shutters & Sails Fishers Island, who know the island house by house.
Stonington Borough is lively all year. Watch Hill and Fishers Island are at their fullest in summer and much quieter in winter. It's worth thinking about how and when you'll use the house before choosing a village.
Many owners rent their houses for part of the summer. We can tell you what comparable houses rent for in each village, so you can factor it into your plans.
Coming soon
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll let you know about coming-soon listings in Stonington, Watch Hill and Fishers Island. One team works across all three villages.
© 2026. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, the CENTURY 21 Logo and C21® are service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Century 21 Real Estate LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each office is independently owned and operated. | New York State Fair Housing Notice
